지산열린학원 로고지산열린학원지산고2 · 25년 10월 · 39번

📌 제시의 요지

수리와 재제조로 폐기를 줄이면 '서비스로서의 제품'이라는 새로운 수요가 생겨 기업도 이윤을 유지할 수 있다.

Reducing waste through repair and remanufacturing creates a new demand, products as a service, so companies can still keep their profits.

🌊 정미의 문단 흐름

도입: 폐기 = 경제의 원동력 — 판매량은 공급·수요와 연결 → 폐기되도록 설계하면 수요 지속. (S1~S3) / 전개: 계획적 노후화·수리 도구 제한·값싼 재료 → 결국 교체품이 필요하게 만듦. (S4~S5) / 결론: [주어진 문장] 수리·재제조로 폐기를 없애면 '서비스로서의 제품'이라는 다른 수요 → 기업은 임대, 유지·수리 서비스로 이윤, 오래가는 제품 개발. (S6~S8)

☠ 수남의 하수인: 계획적 노후화 대장장이

고장 나도록 만든 검 · 폐기에서 서비스로 장면 1
고장 나도록 만든 검 · 폐기에서 서비스로 장면 2
고장 나도록 만든 검 · 폐기에서 서비스로 장면 3
고장 나도록 만든 검 · 폐기에서 서비스로 장면 4

🧚 산이의 어휘

단어뜻동의어 / 반의어
driver원동력= force
be tied to~와 연결되다= be linked to
dependent의존하는= reliant ↔ independent
eventually결국= ultimately
ensure보장하다= guarantee
sustain지속하다= maintain ↔ end
고장 나도록 만든 검 · 폐기에서 서비스로 장면 5
고장 나도록 만든 검 · 폐기에서 서비스로 장면 6
고장 나도록 만든 검 · 폐기에서 서비스로 장면 7
고장 나도록 만든 검 · 폐기에서 서비스로 장면 8
📖 본문 보기

Waste has historically been seen as a necessary driver of the economy. Sales are tied to the amount of a product supplied, which is directly dependent on the demand for that product. Therefore, if you design the product to eventually be wasted, you can ensure that the demand for more products will be sustained. Many strategies have been incorporated into product design and use to ensure that waste is inevitable, such as planned obsolescence, limited access to tools for repairs, and use of cheap materials. All these strategies ensure that the consumer will have limited access to the product in use and will eventually require a replacement. Those who supported the idea that waste is necessary to drive demand failed to realize that prioritizing the elimination of waste via repair and remanufacturing creates a different kind of demand: products as a service. Through this setup, companies simply lease out products that were once sold directly to the customer. With this transition of ownership, companies maintain profit by offering maintenance and repair services and are encouraged to develop long-lasting products.

🏹 시은의 질문 · “한 문장으로 줄이면?”

Instead of designing products to be thrown away, companies can lease and repair them, keeping profit and making long-lasting goods.

버려지도록 제품을 만드는 대신 기업은 임대와 수리로 이윤을 유지하며 오래가는 제품을 만들 수 있다.

🎯 원래 시험 정답

39. 글의 흐름으로 보아, 주어진 문장이 들어가기에 가장 적절한 곳은? [3점]

원래 시험 정답: ④

📝 수지의 문제 풀이 (문장 삽입)

글의 흐름으로 보아, 주어진 문장이 들어가기에 가장 적절한 곳은? [3점]

Those who supported the idea that waste is necessary to drive demand failed to realize that prioritizing the elimination of waste via repair and remanufacturing creates a different kind of demand: products as a service.

Waste has historically been seen as a necessary driver of the economy. Sales are tied to the amount of a product supplied, which is directly dependent on the demand for that product. ( ① ) Therefore, if you design the product to eventually be wasted, you can ensure that the demand for more products will be sustained. ( ② ) Many strategies have been incorporated into product design and use to ensure that waste is inevitable, such as planned obsolescence, limited access to tools for repairs, and use of cheap materials. ( ③ ) All these strategies ensure that the consumer will have limited access to the product in use and will eventually require a replacement. ( ④ ) Through this setup, companies simply lease out products that were once sold directly to the customer. ( ⑤ ) With this transition of ownership, companies maintain profit by offering maintenance and repair services and are encouraged to develop long-lasting products.

  1. ①
  2. ②
  3. ③
  4. ④
  5. ⑤
🗡️ 흑검 ET의 정답 보기

정답 ④ — 원래 시험 39번 정답 ④! 주어진 문장 Those who supported the idea…는 S7 앞에 들어가요. S5 결국 교체품 필요 → (주어진 문장) 서비스로서의 제품이라는 다른 수요 → S7 Through this setup, 즉 ‘이 방식’을 통해 임대! this setup = 서비스로서의 제품.
⚔️ 강신용의 함정: Waste has historically been seen as harmful to the economy… 그럴까? harmful to가 함정이다. a necessary driver of the economy. (S1)
"Waste has historically been seen as harmful to the economy." → 'harmful to'는 틀림 → 'a necessary driver of' (S1)